A precious metals IRA is an ordinary individual retirement account that owns physical gold, silver, platinum or palladium instead of funds or shares. Whether one fits you comes down to three mechanics: how money gets in without a tax bill, who actually holds the metal, and which coins and bars the account may own. This guide answers each from the tax code, the IRS, the mints and the vaults, with the dates we read them.
Quick answer: A precious metals IRA is a self-directed IRA whose custodian buys qualifying gold, silver, platinum or palladium for the account and keeps it at a depository. Money usually arrives by a trustee-to-trustee transfer or a direct rollover, so nothing is withheld. The metal has to stay with the trustee; keeping it at home counts as a distribution.
Key takeaways
- Three separate firms do the work: a custodian runs the account, a dealer sells the metal and a depository stores it. You direct; you don't take delivery.
- A transfer between IRA trustees isn't a rollover in the IRS's eyes, so no tax is withheld and the once-a-year rollover limit doesn't touch it.
- The tax code names the American Eagle coins and lets in bullion at or above the fineness a regulated futures market requires. Custodians turn that into their own accepted lists.
- Goldco is the one company we point readers to. It publishes minimums of $10,000 for a direct purchase and $25,000 for an IRA.
What a Precious Metals IRA Is
Think of two layers. The IRA is the tax wrapper, and a traditional or Roth IRA holding coins follows the same contribution, rollover and distribution rules as one holding a stock fund. The metal is what the wrapper owns, so the account is opened with a custodian that offers self-directed IRAs and works with vaults.
The law starts from a ban. Under section 408(m) of the Internal Revenue Code, an IRA that buys a collectible is taxed as if it had paid the purchase price out to you, and "any metal" and "any stamp or coin" are on the collectibles list. The IRS says such a distribution is generally taxed as ordinary income, and Publication 590-B warns that the 10% additional tax on early distributions may apply too.
The exception, in 408(m)(3), lifts that treatment for:
- the four gold coins in paragraphs (7) through (10) of 31 U.S.C. 5112(a), which are the one-ounce, half-ounce, quarter-ounce and tenth-ounce American Gold Eagles;
- the silver coin in 5112(e), the one-ounce American Silver Eagle;
- the platinum coin under 5112(k), and coins issued under the laws of a state;
- bullion in any of the four metals that is at least as fine as a regulated futures market demands for delivery, provided a trustee physically holds it.
The statute gives no purity figure; it defers to futures-market rules, and custodians write their own. GoldStar Trust, for example, says gold must be .9950 pure, silver .9990, and platinum and palladium .9995, and that bars must come from COMEX, NYMEX or ISO 9000 approved refiners. Equity Trust prints the same minimum fineness figures and its own list of accepted manufacturers. Those are custodian policies, not IRS rules, so the list that binds your account is the one your custodian sends you.
Where Your Metal Actually Sits
When an IRA buys metal, the owner never touches it. You tell the custodian what to buy. The custodian pays the dealer out of the account. The dealer ships the order to a depository, and the depository holds it under the custodian's name for your IRA. Delaware Depository's FAQ puts the chain plainly: bullion held in an IRA "is controlled by the trustee/custodian", and reports and instructions pass between the depository and the custodian, not the account owner. The Texas Bullion Depository says the contents of every inbound IRA shipment are confirmed with the IRA custodian.
| Question | You | Custodian | Dealer | Depository |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds title | The IRA owns the metal; you direct the account | Holds the account and its assets as trustee or custodian | Nothing, once the sale settles | Nothing; it stores metal allocated to the account |
| Who holds the metal | Not you, for as long as it sits in the IRA | Through a depository it has an agreement with | Only until it ships | The vault itself, physically |
| Who reports to the IRS | You, on your own return (an indirect rollover, for instance) | Files Form 5498 for rollovers and contributions and Form 1099-R for payouts | The account's tax forms come from the custodian, not the dealer | Reports go to the custodian, not to the IRS or to you |
| What to ask for in writing | Copies of every transfer form, invoice and statement | Its fee schedule, its accepted-product list and the depositories it uses | An itemized invoice listing each product and quantity, plus its buyback terms | Segregated or pooled storage, and the insurance it carries, via your custodian |
Storage comes in two forms. In segregated storage, Delaware Depository keeps your metal in its own container and returns the exact pieces. In non-segregated (commingled) storage, your Gold Eagles sit with other owners' Gold Eagles, and you get back the same product, not the same pieces. Delaware says segregated storage costs more; the Texas Bullion Depository says it currently offers segregated storage only.
The two vaults differ in other ways. The Delaware Depository is a state-chartered trust company with vaults in Wilmington, Delaware and Boulder City, Nevada, by its own website, and it says it carries $1 billion of all-risk cover through London underwriters, with listed exclusions such as acts of war and cyber-attacks. The Texas Bullion Depository is an agency of the State of Texas run day to day by a contractor, Lone Star Tangible Assets, which received IRS approval as a nonbank trustee in 2023; Texas names Equity Trust Company as the first custodian to work with it, and its policy is underwritten through Lloyd's of London. Your custodian decides which vaults your IRA can use.
How Money Gets In
You can contribute new money (the 2026 IRA limit is $7,500, plus a $1,100 catch-up from age 50), but most metals IRAs start with savings already in another IRA or an old workplace plan. There are three ways to move it.
| Route | Who moves the money | Tax withheld | Once-per-12-months limit | Reporting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trustee-to-trustee transfer (IRA to IRA) | Old custodian pays the new one | None | Doesn't apply | Generally not reported on Form 1099-R or 5498 |
| Direct rollover from a 401(k), 403(b), governmental 457(b) or TSP | Plan pays the IRA directly | None | Doesn't apply | Form 1099-R with code G; Form 5498 box 2 |
| Indirect rollover | Paid to you; you redeposit within 60 days | 20% from a workplace plan; 10% from an IRA unless you opt out | One IRA-to-IRA rollover in any 12 months | Form 1099-R as a payout; Form 5498 box 2 |
The IRS is explicit that a transfer straight from one IRA trustee to another isn't a rollover at all, which is why custodians lean on it; our page on the trustee-to-trustee transfer walks through the forms. The indirect route is where people get hurt. A plan must withhold 20% of a payout sent to you, and to roll over the whole amount you have to replace that 20% from other money within 60 days. Anything not redeposited in time is generally taxable, with a possible 10% additional tax before 59½. The IRS lets people who missed the deadline for one of twelve listed reasons self-certify a late rollover under Revenue Procedure 2020-46, though it can still review that on audit. The 60-day rollover rule page covers the deadline, the waiver and the once-a-year limit in detail.
A workplace plan also pays out only when its own terms allow, such as after you leave the job.
What Goes in It
The table shows where each common product's IRA status comes from: the statute for the American Eagles, custodian lists for nearly everything else.
| Coin or bar | Issuer | Fineness | IRA status | Where that comes from |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| American Gold Eagle | US Mint | .9167 (22-karat); the 1 oz coin weighs 33.931 g and holds 1 troy oz of gold | Named in the statute | 26 U.S.C. 408(m)(3)(A)(i) |
| American Silver Eagle | US Mint | .999 | Named in the statute | 26 U.S.C. 408(m)(3)(A)(ii) |
| American Gold Buffalo | US Mint | .9999 (24-karat) | Accepted by custodians; not named in 408(m)(3)(A) | GoldStar lists "U.S. Buffalo bullion coins" |
| Gold and Silver Maple Leaf | Royal Canadian Mint | .9999 | Accepted by custodians as bullion | GoldStar lists Canadian Maple Leaf coins |
| Krugerrand | Rand Refinery | .9167 (22-carat) | Refused by at least one custodian | GoldStar's unacceptable list |
| Silver buffalo round | Private mints | .999 (one private mint's figure) | Depends on the custodian; no face value | GoldStar accepts "various bars and rounds .999" |
| Gold and silver bars | Refiners | .995+ gold, .999+ silver (custodian minimums) | Accepted from refiners on the custodian's list | GoldStar and Equity Trust |
The American Silver Eagle and the Gold Eagle are the only coins here that the tax code names. If you are weighing the gold coins, our comparison of 1 oz gold coins sets the Eagle, Buffalo, Maple Leaf and Krugerrand side by side. "Silver buffalo" is a trap word: it can mean private silver buffalo rounds, which carry no face value, a 2001 commemorative dollar that is only 90% silver, or the old Buffalo nickel, which has no silver at all. The Canadian Silver Maple Leaf is .9999 fine and carries mint security marks, including radial lines and a micro-engraved leaf. Bars and coins differ in size, divisibility and how widely buyers recognize them; our page on gold coins vs gold bars explains both sides without quoting dealer prices.
Proof coins are the gray area. No IRS page we read addresses proof American Eagles, and the statute doesn't name them either way. GoldStar accepts proofs only ungraded, in original mint packaging and with a certificate of authenticity, and lists the U.S. Buffalo Proof as unacceptable; Equity Trust refuses certified or "slabbed" coins. Ask your custodian before buying one for an IRA.
Gold or Silver
The same IRA rules cover both metals. What differs is how they behave and how much room they take. These figures come from COMEX futures closes, computed by us from daily data through November 4, 2026; they are history, not a forecast, and the chart at the top of this page shows current prices.
| Measure (COMEX futures closes) | Gold | Silver |
|---|---|---|
| Close on 2026-11-04 | $4,073.00 | $52.12 |
| Change over the 10 years to 2026-11-04 | +213% | +184% |
| Annualized volatility, 10 years to 2026-11-04 | 17.1% | 35.5% |
| Largest peak-to-trough fall since August 2000 | −44% (2011 to 2015) | −76% (2011 to 2020) |
| Record close | $5,318.40 on 2026-01-29 | $115.08 on 2026-01-26 |
| Space taken by $10,000 of metal at the 2026-11-04 close | About 4 cm³, 0.2 lb | About 569 cm³, 13.2 lb |
Silver swung roughly twice as hard as gold over that decade, and a given dollar amount of it fills about 145 times the space. The gold-to-silver ratio, the number of silver ounces one gold ounce buys, stood at 78.1 at the November 4 close. Silver also has a large industrial side: the Silver Institute reports that industrial use set another record in 2024, led by electronics, solar panels and cars. Our gold vs silver page sets out the reasons each one suits different buyers, without picking a winner.
Why Goldco
We suggest one company, Goldco, and Goldco may pay us when you contact it through our links. Here is what we weighed, from its own pages as read on November 19, 2026.
- It does both jobs. Goldco says it offers direct purchases of physical metal as well as gold and silver IRAs, so the same firm can handle coins delivered to you and coins bought inside an IRA.
- It prints its minimums. The FAQ on its IRA product pages answers the minimum-purchase question with "$10,000 – Direct Purchase / $25,000 – IRA", so you know before calling whether you qualify.
- It states the condition on its buyback. Goldco will repurchase metal bought from it whenever you ask, but the highest-price version of that promise starts three years after your first Goldco purchase, and Goldco guarantees no specific buyback rate.
- It is plain about home storage. Goldco's FAQ says IRA metal has to be stored at a bullion depository, not at home, which matches the law described above.
Per its BBB profile, read November 19, 2026, the Better Business Bureau rates Goldco A+ and has accredited it since 2011. Goldco's own offer of free silver on qualifying purchases* needs a qualifying purchase; its terms are printed in full below the box.
Goldco is not for everyone. It doesn't suit you if:
- you plan to start below $25,000 in an IRA or $10,000 in a direct purchase, its published minimums;
- you want to keep IRA metal at home, which neither Goldco nor the law allows;
- you want a fee-only adviser. Goldco sells metal and says it gives no financial or tax advice;
- you want a dealer that names its IRA depository up front, since its IRA pages name none.
Our page on Goldco's IRA covers what it sells, how opening an account works, its storage wording, the buyback terms and its public record.
Red Flags
Each of these is a reason to slow down.
- A home-storage IRA pitch. Some sellers describe an IRA, often through an LLC the IRA owns, that lets you keep the coins in your own safe. The IRS treats coins the owner takes into possession as distributed. In McNulty v. Commissioner (2021), the U.S. Tax Court held that an IRA owner who kept IRA-bought American Eagle coins at home had taken a taxable distribution, and it upheld accuracy penalties as well.
- "IRS-approved" coins. The IRS does not approve products or brands. The statute describes which coins and what grade of bullion fall outside the collectibles rule, and custodians decide which products they will take. A seller who says the IRS approved a coin is telling you something no IRS page we read says.
- Collectible upsells inside an IRA. Rare, collectible and graded coins can turn an IRA purchase into a taxable distribution, and custodians such as GoldStar list them as unacceptable. If a salesperson steers you from bullion to a "premium" or limited-edition coin, ask what makes it IRA eligible, who says so in writing, and how much of the price is metal.
- Pressure on the phone. A sound firm puts its terms, its custodian's name and your invoice in writing. A call that wants a decision before you have those papers is a reason to hang up.
- A check made out to you. If anyone suggests you take a payout yourself and buy metal with it, remember the 20% withholding and the 60-day clock. Ask for a transfer or a direct rollover instead.
FAQ
Can I keep the metal in my precious metals IRA at home?
No. Publication 590-B requires IRA coins to remain with the custodian or trustee, and an owner who takes them is treated as having received a distribution. The Tax Court applied that rule in McNulty v. Commissioner in 2021. Metal bought outright with your own money, outside an IRA, can be delivered to you.
Does the IRS approve specific coins?
No. The tax code names the American Eagle gold and silver coins and lets in bullion that meets futures-market fineness, held by a trustee. It publishes no list of approved brands. Custodians publish their own accepted lists, and those differ, so the one that counts is your custodian's.
Can I move a 401(k) into a precious metals IRA while I still work there?
Only if the plan allows a payout. A 401(k) can pay out on events such as leaving the job, reaching 59½ or hardship, depending on the plan document, and hardship payouts can't be rolled over. Ask the plan administrator, and ask for a direct rollover so nothing is withheld.
Are proof coins allowed in an IRA?
No IRS page we read answers that for proof American Eagles, and the statute doesn't use the word "proof". Some custodians accept proofs only ungraded, in original mint packaging and with a certificate; others refuse graded or slabbed coins. Get your custodian's answer in writing before buying one.
What happens if I take the coins out of the IRA?
Taking possession is treated as a distribution, which is generally taxable and may carry the 10% additional tax before 59½. If metal is distributed from an IRA and rolled back within 60 days, the same metal has to go back in; the IRS's 2020 guidance says sale proceeds can't be substituted.
Do gold and silver follow different IRA rules?
No. Both fall under the same section 408(m) exception, and both must be held by a trustee. The difference is practical: silver has swung harder and takes far more vault space for the same dollar amount.
The Guides
How money gets in
How money gets in
The 60-Day Rollover Rule, Explained
The IRS 60-day rollover rule in plain words: the deadline, the once-a-year limit, the 20% withholding trap, the waiver, and why metals IRAs use transfers.
How money gets in
Rollover vs Transfer: Three Ways Money Moves
Transfer, direct rollover or indirect rollover? Who moves the money, how each is reported, which limits apply, and the steps for moving an IRA or 401(k).
Where the metal is stored
Where the metal is stored
Texas Bullion Depository: How It Works
The Texas Bullion Depository explained: a state-run vault, who can open an account, IRA storage as it describes it, deposits, withdrawals and insurance.
Where the metal is stored
Delaware Depository and IRA Storage
What the Delaware Depository is, segregated vs non-segregated storage, how IRA metal gets there and who holds title, and what to ask your custodian.
Which coins and bars
Which coins and bars
American Silver Eagle: Specs, Types and IRA Rules
The American Silver Eagle from the US Mint: weight, fineness, Type 1 vs Type 2, bullion vs proof vs burnished, and why it qualifies for an IRA.
Which coins and bars
1 oz Gold Coins Compared: Eagle, Buffalo and More
The main 1 oz gold coins side by side: purity, gold content, mint, which ones qualify for an IRA, and the Gold Eagle vs Gold Buffalo question.
Which coins and bars
Silver Buffalo: Round vs Coin and IRA Rules
A silver buffalo is usually a private round, not a coin. What that means for its price, its resale and whether it can go in an IRA.
Which coins and bars
Canadian Silver Maple Leaf: Specs and IRA Use
The Royal Canadian Mint's Silver Maple Leaf: .9999 purity, radial lines and the micro-engraved mark, face value, and its place in an IRA.
Which coins and bars
Gold Coins vs Gold Bars
Gold coins or gold bars? How premiums per ounce differ, which is easier to sell, how each is stored, and what the IRA purity rules say about both.
Gold or silver
Gold or silver
Gold vs Silver: Price, Swings and Storage
Gold and silver compared on what can be checked: price history, how far each swings, the gold-to-silver ratio, storage space per dollar and IRA rules.
Sources
- 26 U.S.C. 408, including 408(m) collectibles and 408(d)(3) rollovers
- 31 U.S.C. 5112, the American Eagle and Buffalo coin specifications
- IRS: collectibles in individually directed accounts
- IRS Publication 590-B, Distributions from IRAs
- IRS Publication 590-A, Contributions to IRAs
- IRS: Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions
- IRS: 2026 contribution limits (IR-2025-111)
- IRS Revenue Procedure 2020-46, self-certification of late rollovers
- IRS Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498 (2026)
- IRS: when a retirement plan can distribute benefits
- U.S. Tax Court docket 1377-19, McNulty v. Commissioner
- GoldStar Trust: IRA allowable metals
- Equity Trust: precious metals
- Delaware Depository FAQs
- Delaware Depository: about
- Texas Bullion Depository: IRA storage
- Texas Bullion Depository: dealer shipping instructions
- Texas Bullion Depository FAQs
- Royal Canadian Mint: 2026 Silver Maple Leaf
- Silver Institute: supply and demand
- Goldco: Start a Gold IRA (minimums FAQ)
- Goldco: 5 reasons to buy gold from Goldco (buyback terms)
- Goldco: Gold IRA FAQs
- Goldco on the Better Business Bureau
- All pages above read between 2026-11-12 and 2026-11-19.
- Price figures: COMEX gold and silver futures daily closes (Yahoo Finance), 2000–2026, computed by Amador Gold Guide.