Rollover vs Transfer in 2026: Trustee-to-Trustee and Direct Rollovers Explained
"Rollover" gets used for almost any move of retirement money, but the IRS treats three different moves in three different ways. Which one you use decides whether tax is withheld, whether a deadline applies and what shows up on your tax forms. This guide sets them side by side and walks through funding a precious metals IRA without taking the money into your own hands.
Quick answer: A trustee-to-trustee transfer moves money between IRAs directly; the IRS says it isn't a rollover, nothing is withheld and there's no once-a-year limit. A direct rollover moves money from a 401(k), 403(b), governmental 457(b) or TSP account straight to an IRA with no withholding. An indirect rollover pays you first and starts a 60-day deadline.
Key takeaways
- Transfers and direct rollovers keep the money between institutions. Indirect rollovers put it in your hands, with withholding and a deadline attached.
- An IRA-to-IRA transfer generally isn't reported on Form 1099-R. A direct rollover from a workplace plan is, with code G in box 7.
- The one-rollover-per-12-months rule covers only IRA-to-IRA rollovers. It doesn't apply to transfers or to rollovers out of workplace plans.
- Your plan sets when you can take money out at all. Leaving the job is the example the IRS gives.
- A metals IRA custodian normally requests the money from the old account for you, and the metal goes from the dealer to a depository.
Three Ways Money Moves
Every move of retirement savings fits one of three patterns. The differences come down to who receives the money in between.
| Trustee-to-trustee transfer | Direct rollover | Indirect rollover | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Typical source | Another IRA | 401(k), 403(b), governmental 457(b), TSP | An IRA or a workplace plan |
| Who receives the money | The new IRA custodian | The new IRA or plan | You, then you deposit it |
| Tax withheld | None | None | 20% from a plan; 10% from an IRA unless you elect out |
| Deadline | None | None | 60 days from receipt |
| Once-per-12-months limit | Doesn't apply | Doesn't apply | Applies to IRA-to-IRA rollovers |
| Form 1099-R | Generally not issued | Issued, code G (H for Roth to Roth IRA) | Issued as a distribution |
The rest of this guide takes each column in turn.
Trustee-to-Trustee Transfer
A trustee-to-trustee transfer is the simplest move. Your current IRA custodian sends the money directly to the new one, either because you asked or because the custodian did. Publication 590-A says this isn't a rollover. Nothing is distributed to you, so the move is tax free, and because it isn't a rollover the one-year waiting period between rollovers doesn't touch it.
The IRS ties this to an old ruling. When it adopted the stricter once-a-year rule for IRA rollovers in 2015, its rollover page noted that direct transfers between trustees were unaffected because they aren't rollovers, citing Revenue Ruling 78-406. Announcement 2014-15 says the same.
One detail surprises people: Publication 590-A counts it as a transfer even when the old trustee writes the check to the new trustee but gives it to you to deposit. The test is who the money is paid to, not whose hands carry the envelope.
The IRS rollover page adds that no taxes are withheld from a trustee-to-trustee transfer. For anyone moving an existing IRA into a self-directed account that holds metal, this is the route with the fewest moving parts.
Direct Rollover From a 401(k), 403(b), 457(b) or TSP
A direct rollover is the workplace-plan version of a transfer. You ask the plan administrator to pay your distribution straight to an IRA or another plan. The IRS says the administrator may issue a check made payable to the new account, and that no taxes are withheld.
The reporting instructions for Form 1099-R define the term by the plans it covers: a direct payment from a qualified plan, a section 403(b) plan or a governmental section 457(b) plan to a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA or another eligible retirement plan. The IRS rollover chart explains that qualified plans include, for example, profit-sharing, 401(k), money purchase and defined benefit plans.
Three conditions shape what's possible.
The plan must let money out. The IRS reminds readers that to get a distribution at all, you have to meet the plan's own conditions, such as leaving the job. For 401(k) elective deferrals, the IRS page on distribution timing lists severance from employment, reaching 59½ and hardship as events a plan may permit, and says the plan document must state when a distribution will be made. Hardship distributions can't be rolled over. For 403(b) plans, money taken while still working depends on the plan's terms.
The plan must offer the option. Publication 590-A says a qualified plan must let you have any part of an eligible rollover distribution paid directly to a traditional IRA, though it isn't required to if your eligible distributions are expected to total less than $200 for the year.
Pre-tax money into a Roth IRA is taxable. The IRS rollover chart marks a move from a pre-tax plan to a Roth IRA "Must include in income." A direct rollover into a traditional IRA has no such note.
The Thrift Savings Plan works the same way. Its booklet "Tax Rules about TSP Payments" says rolling a traditional balance into a traditional IRA or eligible employer plan isn't taxed in the current year and has no income tax withheld. The TSP's in-service page says an age-59½ withdrawal carries 20% federal income tax on the taxable portion unless it's rolled into an IRA or eligible employer plan, and allows up to four such withdrawals per calendar year.
Not every payment can be rolled over. The IRS lists required minimum distributions, hardship distributions, loans treated as distributions, payments in a series of substantially equal payments and corrective distributions of excess contributions, among others.
Indirect Rollover in One Paragraph
In an indirect rollover the old account pays you, and you deposit the money in the new account yourself within 60 days of receiving it. A workplace plan must withhold 20% first, and an IRA withholds 10% unless you elect out, so rolling over the full amount means replacing the withheld part from other money. Only one IRA-to-IRA rollover is allowed in any 12-month period across all your IRAs, and anything not redeposited in time is generally taxed, with a possible 10% additional tax under 59½. If an IRA distributes metal, only the same metal can be rolled back. The details, including the waiver routes for a missed deadline, are in our guide to the 60-day rollover rule.
How Each Move Shows Up on Form 1099-R and Form 5498
Two forms follow most moves. Form 1099-R reports money paid out of a plan or IRA. Form 5498 reports what went into an IRA. Both use the IRS's combined Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498.
| Move | Form 1099-R | Form 5498 |
|---|---|---|
| IRA-to-IRA trustee-to-trustee transfer (traditional to traditional, neither a SIMPLE IRA) | Generally not reported | Not reported |
| Direct rollover from a qualified, 403(b) or governmental 457(b) plan | Full amount in box 1, zero in box 2a, code G in box 7 | Box 2, rollover contributions |
| Direct rollover from a designated Roth account to a Roth IRA | Code H | Box 2, rollover contributions |
| Indirect rollover | Reported as a distribution, with a code based on age and exceptions | Box 2, if redeposited within 60 days |
The distribution codes on an indirect rollover depend on your age. The instructions reserve code 7 for a normal distribution when the participant is at least 59½, code 1 for an early distribution with no known exception, and code 2 for an early distribution where the payer knows an exception applies.
A transfer leaves the lightest paper trail of the three, which means fewer forms to reconcile at tax time. How any of this lands on your own return is a question for a tax professional.
Steps to Move Money Into a Precious Metals IRA
The sequence below describes the usual order of events. Your custodian's forms set the exact details.
- Open a self-directed IRA with a custodian that holds metal. Pre-tax money normally goes to a traditional IRA and Roth money to a Roth IRA; the IRS chart says pre-tax plan money moved into a Roth IRA must be included in income.
- Confirm the old account will release the money. For a workplace plan, that means its distribution conditions. For an IRA, ask the old custodian what it needs from you.
- Ask for a transfer or direct rollover. Ask the receiving custodian how it requests the money from the old account. If a plan issues a check, the IRS describes it as made payable to the new account, not to you.
- Choose the metal. Coins and bars have to meet the rules in section 408(m)(3) of the tax code, which names American Eagle coins and sets bullion standards by reference to futures-market fineness. The American Silver Eagle is the silver coin the statute describes, and Publication 590-B lists one-ounce silver coins minted by the Treasury Department among the coins an IRA can hold. Custodians decide which products they accept, so confirm with yours.
- The custodian pays the dealer and the dealer ships to a depository. The Delaware Depository takes instructions on IRA metal only from the custodian. The Texas Bullion Depository says it confirms the contents of inbound IRA shipments with the IRA custodian.
- Check the first statement. It comes from the custodian; look for the metal you bought and the depository holding it.
Goldco lays out a shorter version on its Silver IRA page: open your IRA, fund your self-directed IRA, purchase your precious metals. Its FAQ there says Goldco works with all major self-directed IRA custodians, puts a rollover at "typically less than two weeks," and says metals may take between 1 and 12 weeks to ship. Its published minimums are "$10,000 – Direct Purchase / $25,000 – IRA." Our page on Goldco's IRA covers the rest of what its pages say.
Questions to Settle With the Receiving Custodian
These questions are about your account, not a sales pitch. It helps to have the answers before the money moves.
- Which kind of move is this? Get the custodian to name it: transfer, direct rollover or indirect rollover.
- Where is the money coming from? The old custodian or plan, the account type, and whether any of it is Roth money or after-tax money.
- Who sends the request? And what does the old custodian or plan need from you before it releases the money?
- Which depositories can you use, and which storage type? Segregated storage keeps your own coins apart; non-segregated storage holds identical products together.
- What costs apply, and who sets them? Custodians charge for administration, depositories for storage, and dealers sell above spot. Get each one in writing.
- How will the metal show on statements, and how is it valued? Ask how often statements arrive and what price they use.
- How does a later sale or distribution work? Ask who places the order and where the money or metal goes.
FAQ
Is a trustee-to-trustee transfer a rollover?
No. Publication 590-A says a direct transfer between IRA trustees isn't a rollover. Because nothing is distributed to you, it's tax free and the once-per-12-months limit doesn't apply.
Can a 401(k) be moved to a gold IRA while you still work there?
It depends on the plan. A 401(k) may permit distributions at severance from employment, at 59½ or for hardship, and the plan document says which. Hardship distributions can't be rolled over. Ask the plan administrator what it allows.
Is tax withheld on a direct rollover?
No. The IRS says no taxes are withheld when a plan administrator pays an eligible distribution directly to another plan or an IRA. The 20% withholding applies when the plan pays you.
Does a transfer show up on a tax form?
Generally not. The instructions for Form 1099-R say a trustee-to-trustee transfer from one IRA to another that involves no payment to the participant generally isn't reported, and Form 5498 doesn't report a transfer between traditional IRAs that aren't SIMPLE IRAs.
Can Roth 401(k) money go into a Roth IRA?
Yes. The Form 1099-R instructions use code H for a direct rollover of a designated Roth account distribution to a Roth IRA. Moving pre-tax plan money to a Roth IRA is different: the IRS chart says it must be included in income.
Sources
- IRS: Rollovers of retirement plan and IRA distributions
- IRS Publication 590-A
- Instructions for Forms 1099-R and 5498
- IRS rollover chart (PDF)
- IRS Announcement 2014-15 (PDF)
- IRS: When can a retirement plan distribute benefits?
- 26 U.S. Code § 408
- IRS Publication 590-B
- TSP booklet: Tax Rules about TSP Payments (PDF)
- TSP: In-service withdrawals
- Delaware Depository FAQs
- Texas Bullion Depository: dealer shipping instructions
- Goldco: Start a Silver IRA
Goldco may pay us if you contact it through links on this page. How we are paid.